Categories of knives.
To try and categorize knives these days is nearly impossible. I have tried to break knife designs into eight or nine broad categories but I could probably double or triple the categories and there would still be knives that still fall outside of any describe category. With that said, I think these broad categories will cover about 99% of the knives you come across.
Traditional folders (slip-joint. lockback, automatic, etc.)
The traditional pattern knives can probably be traced back to the first simple folding knife. As time progressed, people would modify their knife to fit the task at hand. So in many ways, the traditional folding knives were all some type of work knife designed for a specific person. Of course the purpose could be as varied as cutting rope, carving wood, neutering cattle, or self-defense.
As time moved on, knives were fitted with multiple blades and then springs were added to keep the blades in place. Later locking springs were added to stop blades from easily folding. Through trial and error the knives morphed into many different styles and so knife makers started assign names or model numbers to the different types of knives. And before you knew it a whole industry of knife makers started making a variety of knives to meet a variety of needs and as the knives fulfilled the task quite well, the patterns standardized and the traditional pattern folding knife was born. In reality there are dozens if not hundreds of different style blades placed into dozens, if not hundreds of different style handles and so in the end there are literally countless combinations of knife styles that make up the “so called” traditional pattern knives.
Among knife collectors, traditional pattern are probably the most collected of any type of knife. And among the traditional pattern knives collected, the most popular pattern is probably the trapper, a large frame two blade jack knife.
Traditional knives are most often collected by older Americans and there is a distinct bias toward American made knives. With that said, some of the traditional patterns were first developed in Britain and Europe and original knives made in Britain and Europe (especially Germany) are quite popular among collectors of vintage knives.
Traditional knives made in China can be well made but will suffer from the “Buy American” bias. This same bias was felt by knives once made in Japan. It is questionable if the bias will pass. Most collectors of Chinese made knives assume that if the quality is there, the value of the knife will eventually be appreciated.
In some cases traditional collectors will normally settle on type of handle material or specific pattern and collect these particular knives. As mentioned, trappers are currently the number one collected traditional pattern. Thus most companies will release more trappers in larger variety than other traditional patterns. Some patterns such as sailing knives and small pattern knives are not made as frequently and are harder to collect.
Among the traditional patterns are also Multi Tool knives. These knives normally contain cutting blades as well as tools such screwdrivers, can-openers, wrenches, scissors, corkscrews, etc. Among the most popular are Boy Scout knives and Swiss Army knives. Brand Collecting.
I would say brand is very common among traditional collectors. Among the American brands, the knives made by W. R. Case & Sons are probably the most collected traditional patterns in the USA if not the entire world. If you plan on collecting by brand, Investigate the brand and if you are satisfied with the product they offer, buy it. Of course, even within brands, some knives will vary in quality. For instance, a company renowned for its fixed blade knives may make less than quality folding knives and vice-versa.
So it is just as vital to learn what the company prides itself on and the reputation among its various patterns. You may also consider where certain knives are made within the brand. Some companies are known for only making knives in one location whereas other companies have knives made at several locations and then put their brand on all the products. This may lead to problems with quality control. Always investigate a company’s warranty and return policy. A good brand will have a clear cut, easy to understand warranty and a no hassle return policy. Many custom knife makers even offer 100% money-back guarantees.
Traditional fixed blades (Work knives, Bowies, hunters, skinners)
Traditional fixed blades can be traced back to the Stone Age. Regardless of what style the knife is, it is a blade with a tang protruding into a handle. These can be anything from a paring knife used for an apple to machetes. Also any type of work knife that does not fold is considered a traditional fixed blade. Most people, however, think of traditional fixed blades as those used in hunting, camping, fishing, or other outdoors endeavors. Traditional fixed blades also include the numerous daggers and small knives carried for personal protection and often concealed while being carried. Machetes and other bush-craft knives should also be considered traditional fixed blades
Traditional combat and fighting knives
Collectors of military knives want knives that were actually used in a war were issued by a branch of the military service. Among these are: • issued knives (knives made under a military contract for a branch of the military service). • Knives made by soldiers or for soldiers during wartime in a theater of operation (theater) • Knives marketed to soldiers and bought through private purchase and used in combat. In the US, most collectors of military knives collect material used in World War II. Probably close behind that is material from the Vietnam Conflict. But for the most part if the knife was used by the military in a war or some other military operation it will have greater appeal --as long as the use can be authenicated. If it was just around at the time but there is no proof of actual use, its value will be less. Thus the dating of military knives becomes critical. As you can imagine, most of these knives have been replicated. Many have even been reissued or remade to exacting standards, with the same grades of steel and other material being used in its manufacturing. Regardless of the quality and how good the copy is, it is still a replica. An example would be Ontario’s M3 Trench knife, which is fairly close copy of the Camillus M3 Trench knife. Some of the Camillus knives were used in WWII Many were used post WWII. The Ontario knife is every bit as good as the Camillus but it is not being marketed to soldiers serving in Afghanistan. While some soldiers may actually carry it into combat in Afghanistan, it is doubtful the knife will ever be associated with that war. The Ontario version is a copy of the 1943 trench knife and does not remain in government inventory. This doesn’t demean the quality of the build; it is only a comment on its potential to become more valuable. Afgahnistan is not the war this particular knife is associated with. The M3 is a knife assoicated with WWII therefore, the best that can be said for an M3 used in Afganistan is that the design of the knife has stood the test of time and can still get the job done. At the same time, such knives as the Air Force Survival Knife and the Marine Corp Fighting Knife, remain in government inventory and are sold on base through the Class II stores and post-exchange. Many would consider these knives genuine military issue knife, even though most soldiers will need to purchase the knife form his/her own funds. This is especially true of the The Marine Corp fighting knife which has remained a item of interest to collector since its inception. Many knife collectors are capable of dating the various production runs to specific wars and military operations. If these knife see service in Afghanistan, they will be considered a veteran of that conflict. The liklihood of the Marine Corp Fighting Knife being a sought after collector’s item in years to come is much higher than that of Afghan era M3 trench knife.
Folk Art / Theater Knives
Folk Art is a broad category that covers hand painted knives, primitive knives, knives made as art, knives of indigenous populations and even purpose made knives for a specific historic event or circumstance. So, from this starting point, a number of knives can be considered folk-art!
When it comes to Folk Art Knives, it all comes down to the fame and renown of the folk artist who made it or the group of people it represents. A copy of an original folk art knife is just that! A poster of the Mona Lisa is not worth the same as the Mona Lisa. Folk Art can be anything from a hand forged one of kind knife or just an old knife that has been hand painted by a folk artist! Folk and Art knives are knives with painted scenery or sculpted handles and sheaths. This can include scrimshaw work when done by hand and not via laser etching. However, if the hand painted scenery is mass produced in a factory most collectors will not consider it true folk art and its value will most likely not go up and runs a strong potential of actually going down in value. The ones created by well-known artists are going to be one of kind, expensive and are normally considered collectible.
Of special interest to some people are knives made by and indigenous peoples from around the world. (This includes the knives made by Native Americans including the Inuits) These are some time referred to as Primitive or Tribal knives.
Knives that are truly hand-made and incorporate that actual culture of an indigenous group are highly valued and respected. Items that are made for the souvenir trade are not as highly valued; especially if the item is massed produced in a country other than that of the indigenous population.
Theater Knives are a special category of folk art. The name does not refer to prop knives from plays and movies but knives made or modified in the Theater of War for use by combatants. For the most part, this normally refers to knives made during WWII. Theater knives played a vital role during the war due the lack of knives being supplied to soldiers. In the early part of the war, not every soldier was issued a knife or bayonet and they had to do with whatever they could get. In many cases, this meant having a loved one mail them an old hunting knife. As these knives were not as robust as military issue, handles would often be replaced or blade profiles would be changed.
The military also started contracting with numerous manufacturers and began requesting existing stocks of large hunting knives as substitutes until adequate numbers of the military authorized contracts were in full production. Other smaller knife makers such as Hoyt Buck and John Ek, began producing new knives that while not issued knives could be found at base and post exchanges for purchase. The always resourceful American GI, who sometimes had access to the right tools also started making or modifying knives in the field for personal use or for their fellow soldiers. These knives are often known today as theater knives. Many theater knives were converted from bayonets, hunting knives, agricultural tools, broken knives, old files, or any other suitable steel that could ground, shaped and sharpened. Others were local made by civilians to the specification of the combatant.
Handle material came from all sources imaginable including the Plexiglas canopies of airplanes and old boots. Small local companies of allied nations and/or liberated areas also saw the potential of aiding the war effort and making a small profit at the same time. Many started producing knives made to specifications of a soldier or group of soldiers; leading to such items as the Middle East Commando knife and a variety of Knuckle-duster knives in the the Pacific.
While the term Theater knife brings up images of World War II, in reality homemade knives have been seen in every war and come from every nation. For examply the D-Guard Bowie could be considered a theater knife from the American Civil War. A broader defintion for a theater knife might be it a knife that 1) was made or modified in the area where the fighting was taking place 2) was used by the combantant, and 3) was an issued knife that was modified to the fit the needs of the combatant for the specific conflict .
The quality and style of theater knives vary dramatically and in many cases it is hard to verify that the knife is not just homemade junk, or a hand crafted farm knife. However, when a genuine theater knife is verified, it can be as valuable as some of the rarest fighting knives of the war. But as mentioned, many homemade knives are passed off as theater knives with no actual proof they were made in theater of war or used by a combatant. At the end of the day, a theater knife is only worth what someone will pay and could easily become nothing more than a curiousity.
For lack of a better definition modern knives refer to post World War II made knives that take advantage of new or improved synthetic materials and modern steel alloys and explore new design concepts to produce a knife that is more ergonomic and functional than older, more traditional knives. To be fair, knife design is in a constant state of evolution with each new generation of knife makers looking at how to make knives more robust, versatile, sharper, and easier to maintain. With that said, let us delve into post WWII.
Modern Folders (Tactical, SAR)
The modern folder is without a doubt the fast growing category of knives in America and probably worldwide. As well it should be as these are basically the natural evolution of traditional folders using new steels and synthetic materials designed during World War II. The idea of the materials was to make a knife better, faster, and cheaper.
The design of the knives is normally very austere, with function driving form. Most modern models are a single blade knife designed so that blade employment can be done with one hand operation. The knives normally lack back springs and are deployed using bearings or torsion springs or simply a flick of a thumb stud and gravity. They are normally held in the closed position by friction or simple locking mechanisms. The blades are normally held in place by the use of liner, frame or back-lock. The scales on modern folders tend to be made of modern composite materials; such as fiber reinforced thermoplastics, or high grade light weight metals. A common feature on almost all modern folders is a belt or pocket clip.
These knives are sometimes called a Tactical Folder. The term is actually misleading and is more of a sales gimmick than actual pattern. In most cases the modern folder is a updated version of a one blade folding hunter or simply a jack knife.
The SAR or Search & Rescue is a type of folding knife that is attempt to make a modern folding survival knife. The knives usually includes features that would be helpful in emergency situations such as vehicular entrapments, or water rescues. The most common feature is normally an integrated glass breaker in the pommel of the knife. Another common feature is a seatbelt or line cutter integrated into the handle.
While in many cases, modern folders are marketed toward first responders and the military, for the most part they are not made under under contract for these organizations.
Some things to look out for when collecting Modern Folders:
Modern fixed blades (Composites, new steels, etc)
The modern fixed blades are those that take a new look at the old traditional knife patterns and often incorporate new materials in their construction. The new knives also explore different blade grinds and shapes to increase the usefulness of a single blade.
The knives also incorporate new or overlooked features that were found lacking in older knives such as a gut hooks, partially serrated blades, saw backs, and other features. For the most part, many of the features in modern fixed blades have been around for decades or even centuries. The difference is in the presentation and the combination of borrowed concepts and ideas from the wealth of acquired world knowledge.
For instance, a popular choice among the modern hunter is the use of the drop point blade and other modified blade profiles designed to make them work more efficiently in a variety of tasks. Probably the most common feature however has to be the use of new materials for blade grips and sheaths which make the knives more resilient when used outdoors. Even the idea of having removable handle scales to add versatility to the blade and aid in maintenance.
A variety of plastics and nylon used in sheaths instead of leather. (Again not a new concept considering the U.S. Military began issuing mildew resistant plastic sheaths in WWII!) You will also see more stainless steel used in blades. However, this is due to vast improvements in Stainless Steels since WWII. Materials such as fiber reinforced nylons and thermoplastics are used for handles instead of the more traditional, stag or bone or wood. Almost every traditional fixed blade knife has a modern day equivalent.
The fastest growing market among the modern combat knife is probably the bushcraft knife. The idea is to make a one knife that can accomplish every conceivable task the user might encounter. The concept is not new. The driving forces seem to be surviving combat and surviving in the wilderness. And today’s knife makers and designers are always attempting to improve on past designs. Obviously when a design becomes popular it is often copied and tweaked.
Today’s modern combat fixed blades are also driven by this market. Most tend to be full tang knives with slab sided screwed on handles or skeleton frames suitable for cord wrapping. Just as the modern fixed blades are based on early traditional knives, the modern combat knives can easily be traced by to earlier combat knives. Some of the modern knives are clearly designed for self-defense, close quarter combat, or survival needs while others are designed for multi-use roles. While many are made for and even used by military or law enforcement personnel few are actually made under government contract.
The Bushcraft knives also come in a variety of shapes with their main purpose being the ability to do a variety of outdoor tasks. In many cases, factories and makers do minor design changes to an old pattern and an old knife becomes a new Bush crafting knife.
Exotic (Fanatasy, Movie, and Historical recreations
The exotics include movie reproduction, fantasy blades, Historical Recreations (such as medieval swords and daggers).
Buying exotic knives is risky business if you’re in it for a profit. The only ones apt to go up in value are those that are first production runs, one of a kind small batch designs, were actually used in a movie, or really fall into the custom made category. In most cases, these will need letters of authenticity to prove their worth. Other exotics will probably not go up much in value, especially if they are made of low quality materials or are mass produced and readily available. This goes for fancy swords, reproduction bowie knives and just about any other exotic knife.
By all means, I’m not trying to discourage anyone from buying an exotic knife. Many just look really cool and make a nice conversation piece. My point is that you make sure of the knife’s real value before buying it. Make sure the materials used to make the knife are as advertised. Ask questions. So many items, especially those sold online are made of low quality material, fake wood, imitation stones, low quality steel, etc. They are in fact such poor quality that they aren’t even worthy of the title “knife” Don’t buy any exotic, movie, or folk knife under the assumption that it will be a great future investment. Buy it because you like it, and because it is a fair deal at the time of purchase.
The best of the exotics are first run custom made knives sold in limited runs using high quality materials. These will normally retain their value and may come up in value over time. An anniversary issue or second run exotic knife will probably not go up in value. If you feel like buying it understand that it will just be a reminder of that first run exotic that you missed out on.
The Hybrids really aren’t a category but it the forging of different knife styles, patterns or histories to create something new. It is the bluring of lines between modern and traditional. It is the cross cultural blending of knife concepts.
As you can expect, you will find modern knife designs that incorporate traditional qualities as well as traditional knives that feature aspects of the modern folders and fixed blades. This should come as no surprise as traditional knife makers will also want to take advantage of new materials and design concepts and modern knife makers will continue to re-imagine traditional knife patterns.
But the hybrids go beyond the melding of of the old and new or the archeologic record of the knife. It also looks at borrowing from its anthropology or cultural formation. The Hybrids incorporate ideas from different indigenous group and integrate these concepts into new patterns. It is the idea of blending the obscure and forgotten with known and broadly accepted. With the hybrids, knife makers not only take a fresh look at old concepts but combine old concepts with new ideas. Of Course, this is just a continuation of the history of the Knife; tracing back to our first ancestor first took stone to flint and created the first knife. (The only difference is today, you can by a factory manufactured copy of a flint knife made of fake flint for about $15!)
Next Section: Custom vs. Customized
Return to Index/Main Page